Does Pilates increase strength

For anyone who has experienced a progressive program of Pilates they would answer ‘yes’ to this question. There is a significant progression from beginner to advanced and from one piece of equipment to another.

Pilates for injury rehabilitation

If you are using Pilates for a muscle, joint injury or post-surgery the answer is a definite yes! Soft tissue and joint injuries require low-load resistance exercises. The focus should be on mobility with light resistance. Injured joints and soft tissues require progressive resistance to heal and become stronger. Pain also resolves with gradual movement and resistance.

The Pilates equipment is ideal for pain and rehabilitation. The spring tension can be adjusted from very light to strong and can progress an injury from the acute/painful stage to full recovery. The novel equipment allows joints to be supported and mobilized, so that the injury is not over-loaded.

The vast repertoire in Pilates exercises allows us to vary the particular exercise to each person and their injury. A perfect example of the versatility of Pilates is the rehabilitation of a knee anterior-cruciate ligament injury. The initial protocol for this post-operatively is to start light mobility and resistance and gradually increase from non-weight bearing to full weight-bearing exercises. The Pilates reformer is ideal for both these approaches.

Pilates, muscle fibres and strength

There is some debate on social media if Pilates is enough for general strengthening, compared to lifting heavier weights.

Pilates is excellent at training the nervous system to recruit the type of muscle fibres that are postural, low endurance and stabilizing. These are type 1 muscle fibres. Our muscles can also function as power muscles that respond to heavy lifting. These are type 2 muscle fibres. Our muscles have a combination of both type 1 and 2 fibres. The activation of each depends on the demand placed on the muscle. For example, the gluteal muscle may use type 2 power fibres when doing a bridge or deadlift. When balancing on one leg, the gluteal works in a stabilizing way, using more type 1 fibres.

Image 1 shows how the muscles fibres are arranged between type 1 and 2 and the different function.

Muscle fibres and motor units
Image 1. Muscle fibres and motor units.

We have muscles that are local and global stabilizers. For example, in the spine the deep back muscles and hip flexors are local stabilizers; the middle back muscles are global stabilizers; the latissimus and six pack abdominal muscles are global mobilizers. Pilates trains the local and global muscles very well, as they respond to low load resistance.

The impression is that low-load Pilates type exercises can’t make your muscles bigger or stronger. However the science doesn’t support that. Muscles can fatigue and get stronger by changing the way you stimulate them: increasing repetitions and the complexity; changing the lever mechanics, doing the exercises slowly. By changing these parameters more muscles fibres are recruited and that’s what makes you stronger.

If you are only looking to increase muscle size, then you need to lift heavy weights to do this. However, the body needs to recruit the stability and endurance muscle fibres to support this. You still need to train your muscles to develop stability, endurance and motor control to support heavy resistance.

What determines muscle strength?

Muscle strength is not only determined by the amount of weight you lift. Strength also depends on the following:

Motor unit recruitment

How many motor units you recruit – by increasing the difficulty of the exercises to make the muscle work more, you activate more motor units.

When the exercises are more complex, you use both type 1 and type 2 muscle fibres.

Endurance

Endurance – this is the ability of muscles to work for longer, before fatiguing. Doing slow exercises and higher repetitions increases their endurance.

Motor control

Motor control – this is training the muscles to work in a coordinated way, both for stability and strength. Pilates uses multiple muscles to perform an exercise. Some muscles are stabilizing while others are your main movers.

Stability

Stability– certain exercises are better at training the muscles to control movement around joints. These are lower load exercises and use type 1 muscle fibres.

The take-home message

Most of our muscles have different functions. Muscle strength is not limited to just power or size. This is why doing a seemingly low-resistance Pilates exercises can feel challenging. Because it’s working a combination of muscle characteristics.

  • Pilates can recruit both type 1(postural and endurance) and type 2 muscle fibres (strength and power)
  • Research has shown that even low load/resistance can produce significant muscular strength adaptation, even lifting 30% of your one rep maximum lift.
  • The back muscles are a good example of muscles that have both types of muscle fibres. Stability, endurance (type 1) and strength (type 2).
  • Pilates can develop muscular endurance and neuromuscular control through low-load contractions. Increasing resistance can increase the strength demands on the muscles.
  • Pilates often works muscles where they have to produce relatively lower forces for prolonged periods, while maintaining precise joint and trunk positioning. As exercise intensity, resistance or fatigue increases, additional higher threshold motor units can be recruited, thereby increasing strength.
Meet Damian

Damian Wyard

Damian Wyard has been a registered physiotherapist since 2003. He has also been teaching Pilates for over 20 years. In his unique practice, he combines physiotherapy treatments with Pilates rehabilitation, using the classic equipment. Damian blends manual therapy, sports massage and Pilates to rehabilitate most musculo-skeletal injuries/conditions. He uses Pilates-based exercise to treat both acute and persistent pain. Damian is always keeping up to date with the research and new skills, so that patients receive the best care. To learn more about Damian, read his full bio here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *